SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

 
vol.45 número4Perda de carbono em resíduos de origem vegetal: efeito das características (bio)químicas iniciaisFertilidade do solo e nutrição mineral da “Batata-doce de Aljezur” índice de autoresíndice de materiabúsqueda de artículos
Home Pagelista alfabética de revistas  

Servicios Personalizados

Revista

Articulo

Indicadores

Links relacionados

  • No hay articulos similaresSimilares en SciELO

Compartir


Revista de Ciências Agrárias

versión impresa ISSN 0871-018Xversión On-line ISSN 2183-041X

Rev. de Ciências Agrárias vol.45 no.4 Lisboa dic. 2022  Epub 01-Dic-2022

https://doi.org/10.19084/rca.28476 

Artigo

Analytical laboratories for soil fertility assessment, in Portugal

Laboratórios de avaliação da fertilidade do solo, em Portugal

Raquel Mano*1 

Fernanda Rebelo1 

1INIAV, I.P./UEIS-SAFSV/Avenida da República, Quinta do Marquês, 2780-157, Oeiras, Portugal


Abstract

The main objective of this work was to obtain updated data from soil fertility laboratories located in Portugal. A survey was sent to the Heads of 32 laboratories and a reply was received from 25 of them. 14 of these labs belong to the Ministry of Education, 7 are private and 4 to the Ministry of Agriculture. In addition to soil they also analyse plant material and, the majority, organic soil improver and irrigation water. In the minimum package of analyses they offer (Summary Analysis) pH, organic matter, extractable phosphorus and potassium are always included and 72 % of them also include field texture. But this package differs greatly between labs with regard to the inclusion of other parameters. 76 % of the labs issue fertilisation recommendations, but only 20 % do so automatically. There is a relative homogeneity of methods for the parameters of the summary analysis, except for organic matter. Only two laboratories have accredited tests. The existence of a national interlaboratory test is felt to be important for internal quality control and harmonisation of methodologies.

Keywords: fertiliser recommendations; nutrient management; plant nutrition; soil test; soil analysis

Resumo

O objetivo principal deste trabalho foi obter dados atualizados dos laboratórios que, em Portugal, analisam solo para avaliar a fertilidade do solo e apoiar a atividade agrícola no tocante à nutrição e fertilização das culturas. Enviou-se um inquérito aos responsáveis técnicos de 32 laboratórios, tendo recebido resposta de 25 deles. 14 destes lab. pertencem ao Ministério da Educação, 7 são privados e 4 do Ministério da Agricultura. Para além de solo analisam também material vegetal e, a maioria, corretivos orgânicos e águas de rega. No pacote mínimo de análises que oferecem (Análise sumária) todos analisam o pH, matéria orgânica, fósforo e potássio extraíveis e, em 72 % deles, também a textura de campo. Mas este pacote difere muito entre laboratórios no tocante à inclusão de outros parâmetros. 76 % dos laboratórios emitem recomendações de fertilização, mas apenas 20 % o fazem automaticamente. Existe relativa homogeneidade de métodos para os parâmetros da análise sumária, exceto no tocante à matéria orgânica. Apenas dois laboratórios têm ensaios acreditados. A existência de um teste Interlaboratorial nacional é sentida como importante para o controlo interno de qualidade e harmonização de metodologias.

Palavras-chave: análise do solo; análise de terra; gestão de nutrientes; recomendações de fertilização; nutrição das plantas

INTRODUCTION

Knowledge of the state of soil fertility, through soil analysis, is essential to enable the establishment of a rational fertilization plan, fundamental to ensure good crop production, in a context of increasing economic and environmental constraints.

The main objectives of this work were: (1) to survey the soil fertility labs operating in Portugal; (2) to know what other matrices were analysed, related to crop fertilisation and nutrition; (3) to know which analytical methodologies were predominantly used.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

In March 2022 a survey was sent to the Heads of 32 soil analysis laboratories in Portugal. 25 labs responded to the survey. Of the 7 labs that did not respond: 3 informed that they did not perform soil fertility analysis; 2 (Eurofins Agrotesting and AGQ labs.) informed that they receive samples, but these are analysed in a lab based outside the country, choosing not to respond to the survey; 2 labs, despite confirming to analyse soil fertility, did not respond.

Location of the laboratories

Most of the laboratories belong to the Ministry of Education (14), 4 belong to the Ministry of Agriculture and 7 are private, spread over the mainland and islands (Figure 1). In 16 of them, most of the analyses performed in 2021 were for direct support to agricultural activity.

Figure 1 Soil fertility laboratories in Portugal. 

Materials analysed within the frame- work of soil fertility, plant nutrition and crop fertilization

Nearly all labs analysing soil also analyse plant material. This is followed by organic soil improver (68 % of the labs) and irrigation water (64 %). To a lesser extent fertilizer (36 %) and liming material (32 %) (Table 1).

Table 1 Materials analysed by the different labs 

Location Laboratory S PM IW F LM OSI
Almeirim Agroeno × × × ×
A. Heroísmo UAçores × × ×
Beja ESA Beja ×
Beja LAGRA × × × × × ×
Bragança ESA Bragança × × ×
Camacha DRA Madeira × × ×
C. Branco ESA C. Branco × × ×
Coimbra ESA Coimbra × × × ×
Elvas ESA Elvas × × × ×
Évora AmbiTerra × × ×
Faro UAlg-LAQ × × × × × ×
Guarda LabMIA × × × ×
Guimarães A2-Análises Quím. × × × × × ×
Lisboa INIAV-LQARS × × × × × ×
Lisboa ISA-Quím. Agríc. × × × ×
Lisboa ISA-Pedologia × × × ×
Lisboa SGS MultiLab × × × ×
Montijo Agroleico × × × × × ×
Oeiras INIAV-Lab. Solos × × × × ×
Pte. Lima ESA V. Castelo × × ×
Porto EOR × × ×
Porto Salvo ISQ-Labqui × × × × ×
Santarém ESA Santarém × ×
Tavira NAPALGARVE × × ×
Vila Real UTAD × × × ×

S - Soil; PM - Vegetal material; IW - Irrigation water; F - Fertilizer; LM - Liming material; OSI - Organic soil improver.

Parameters currently analysed for the purpose of fertilisation recommen-dations

The labs generally propose analytical programmes, simpler for annual crops, or more complete for the establishment of tree or shrub crops. The analytical package commonly called summary analysis (SA) generally includes the extractable content of the main nutrients, as well as the three parameters that most influence both the availability of these nutrients to the plant and the capacity of the soil to retain water: pH, organic matter (OM) and texture (Table 2).

Table 2 Parameters covered in the Summary analysis programme and issuing of fertilisation recommendations 

Laboratory pH OM P K FT Mg N LR O FR
Agroeno (1,2) × × × × × n
UAçores (1) × × × × × × a
ESA Beja (1) × × × × or
LAGRA (1) × × × × × × × or
ESA Bragança (1,2) × × × a
DRA Madeira (1,2) × × × n
ESA C. Branco (1) × × × × or
ESA Coimbra (1) × × × × × or
ESA Elvas (1,2) × × × × × × or
AmbiTerra (1) × × × × × or
UAlg-LAQ (1) × × × × × × or
LabMIA (1,2) × × × × n
A2-Anális. Quím. (1,3) × × × × × × × a
INIAV-LQARS (1) × × × × × × a
ISA-Quím. Agríc. (1) × × × × × × or
ISA-Pedologia (1) × × × × × or
SGS MultiLab (1) × × × × × n
Agroleico (1,2,3) × × × × × × n
INIAV-Lab. Solos (1) × × × × × × n
ESA V. Castelo (1) × × × × × × or
EOR (1,2) × × × × × × × or
ISQ-Labqui (1,2,3) × × × × × × or
ESA Santarém (1) × × × × × or
NAPALGARVE (1) × × × × × × × or
UTAD (1,2) × × × × × a

(1) pH-H₂O; (2) pH-KCl; (3) pH-CaCl₂; FT - Field texture; N - total nitrogen; LR - Lime requirement; O - Other parameters; FR - fertiliser recommendations; n - no; or - on request; a - always.

It was found that there is a great variability in the parameters proposed by the labs: pH, OM, extractable phosphorus (P) and potassium (K) are always included in the SA. The same is not true for the other parameters, field texture being included in 72 % of the cases, extractable magnesium (56 %), "lime" requirement (44 %) and total nitrogen (32 %).

The issue of fertiliser recommendations by the labs is a clear advantage for the farmers, who thus have a good basis for rational fertilization of their crops. 19 of the 25 surveyed labs (76 %) issue fertiliser recommendations, but in only 5 labs are these done automatically. In the remaining 14, only on request (Table 2).

Analytical methodology followed in the Summary Analysis parameters

Harmonisation of methods is important at a world and national level, in order to improve the comparability of results. It is, however, difficult to achieve, especially in the case of plant-available nutrients, as it involves much more than laboratory analysis (history of studies, such as field trials, type of soils, etc.). In 2017 FAO launched the Global Soil Laboratory Network (GLOSOLAN), involving more than 740 laboratories worldwide. It aims to harmonise many of the operating procedures in this area, making them freely available.

pH: All labs include pH-H₂O in the SA. Seven of them also use pH-KCl and two include in addition pH-CaCl₂. The proportion soil: extractant is 1:2.5 (m/v) in 64 % of the labs, being 1:5 v/v (ISO 10390 standard) in 32 % of the labs (Figure 2).

Organic matter: Except in the case of loss on ignition, OM is always obtained by multiplying the soil organic carbon (SOC) content by 1.724. Dry combustion is the method which gives the total SOC content. It is the preferred one in international studies (FAO, 2020), being followed by 6 labs. However, most labs (15) use dichromate oxidation, either potassium dichromate (8) or sodium dichromate (7).

Due to the incomplete oxidation of SOC by dichromate (circa 77 %), a correction factor of 1.3 has been proposed (Kalra & Manyard, 1992; FAO, 2020). This factor was confirmed by Dias et al. (2005) for Portuguese soils. However, only 5 of the 15 labs employing dichromate said they use a correction factor. Other 7 do not use it and 3 did not answer. The use of this correction factor should be very clear in the analysis report, to allow a proper comparison of results from different laboratories.

Figure 2 Main methods of soil analysis for pH, organic carbon, extractable P and K, in Portugal. 

P and K are extracted using the Ammo-nium lactate/acetic acid method (Egnér et al., 1960) in about 80% of the laboratories, but ¼ of them also use the Olsen method for P (Olsen et al., 1954), depending on the pH of the soil. For Mg, 1M ammonium acetate at pH7 predo-minates. The lime requirement is obtained by calculation in 15 of the 25 labs and dosed in 5 others.

Only two of the labs - ISQ and Lagra - have accredited tests. Several labs indicated the need for a National soil testing programme, for proficiency testing and methodology harmonisation.

CONCLUSIONS

In Portugal, there is a large network of 25 soil fertility labs. pH, OM, extractable P and K are the parameters always analysed in the minimum analytical programme. There is a relative homogeneity of methods for these parameters, except for organic matter. 76 % of the labs issue fertiliser recommendations, but only 20 % do so automatically. Only two have accredited tests. There is a need for a national soil testing programme.

Acknowledgements

To all the heads of soil fertility laboratories, whose information was crucial for this survey.

This work is within the framework of the European EJP Soil programme "Towards climate-smart sustainable management of agricultural soils", funded by the European Union's H2020 research and innovation programme under agreement no. 862695.

References

Dias, R.M.S.; Sempiterno, C.M. & Simões, A.M. (2005) - Determinação do Carbono orgânico em solos. Estudo comparativo da Norma ISO 10694 e do método de oxidação por via húmida com doseamento colorimétrico. Lisboa: Instituto Nacional de Investigação Agrária e das Pescas /Laboratório Químico Agrícola Rebelo da Silva (INIAP/LQARS), 8p. [ Links ]

Egnér, H.; Riehm, H. and Domingo, W. (1960) - Unter-suchungen über die chemische bodenanalyse als grundlage für die beurteiling des nährstoffzustandes der böden: II. Chemische extraktionsmethoden zur phosphor und kaliumbestimmung. Kungliga Lantbrukshög-skolans Annaler, vol. 26, p. 199-215 [ Links ]

FAO (2020) - A protocol for measurement, monitoring, reporting and verification of soil organic carbon in agricultural landscapes - GSOC-MRV Protocol. Rome. [ Links ]

Kalra, Y.P. & Maynard, D.G. (1992) - Méthodes d’analyse des sols forestiers et des tissues végétaux. Edmonton, Alberta, Canada: Forêts Canada, Région du Nord-Ouest, Centre Foresterie du Nord. Rapp. inf. NOR-X-319F, 129p. [ Links ]

Olsen, S.B.; Cole, C.V.; Wanatabe, F.S. and Dean, L.A. (1954) - Estimation of available phosphorus in soils by extraction with sodium bicarbonate. - USDA: Circular 939, p. 1-19. [ Links ]

Creative Commons License This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License